Friday, March 06, 2009

Ranking the Descendents/All

I did one of these recently for U2 and at Dave's suggestion decided to go ahead and rank the albums for the Descendents and All.

Technically, these are the same band but I chose to split them out because trying to rank all of these albums on their own is not something I want to try and get into at this time.

Anyway, here they are. The albums of the Descendents and All in order of preference!

Thanks for the suggestion Dave!

Descendents

Everything Sucks
Merican
Cool To Be You
Enjoy!
I Don't Want to Grow Up
All
Milo Goes to College
Bonus Fat

ALL

Pummel
Problematic
Mass Nerder
Breaking Things
Allroy's Revenge
Allroy Saves
Allroy for Prez
Allroy Sez
Percolator

5 comments:

  1. Here’s my lists…

    Descendents
    1. ‘Merican
    2. Cool To Be You
    3. I Don’t Want To Grow Up
    4. Milo Goes to College
    5. ALL
    6. Everything Sucks
    7. Bonus Fat
    8. Enjoy

    ALL
    1. Breaking Things
    2. Problematic
    3. Allroy Sez
    4. Allroy’s Revenge
    5. Percolator
    6. Allroy for Prez
    7. Mass Nerder
    8. Pummel
    9. New Girl, Old Story
    10. Allroy Saves

    ReplyDelete
  2. So it is safe to say that your favorite ALL singer is Chad Price, yes?

    Ranking these in a way is hard because I love (or at least really like) all of these albums.

    I am a bit surprised to see Enjoy so high on your list and Percolator so low though.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Yeah, it is pretty safe to say that. Although some of the older singers sung on some tunes that were really really good. "She's My Ex" "Just Perfect" and "Skin Deep" to name a few off the top of my head.

    I put Enjoy! higher on the list because it has a lot of songs on it that I like while Percolator just didn't have a whole lot of songs that did it for me, other than "Dot".

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hey man just reading your blog, had to comment... I know it's all about opinions, but I think your ALL list is around about exactly the opposite of what mine would be! I guess you favour the Chad years right?

    Here's mine...

    Allroy's Revenge
    Allroy For Prez
    Percolater
    Allroy Saves
    Breaking Things
    Mass Nerder
    Pummel
    New Girl, Old Story (Guitar Case is one of the best tunes laid down)
    Allroy Sez
    Problematic

    I'd probably squeeze the 'Best Of' record in there near the top because it totally gives the songs a different vibe/complexion, and I'm not including Trailblazer, ya know, for the obvious reasons...

    Keep it up man...

    ReplyDelete
  5. "Guitar Case" is an AMAZING song!

    ReplyDelete